Fact-checking and its detractors
Fact-checking has become a familiar tool for political reporters to hold office-holders and candidates accountable. But critics ask if fact-checkers sometimes miss the forest for the trees, and if the practice often struggles with false equivalency the way conventional political coverage does.
The Latest
Trump and Musk Amplify Long-Ago Debunked Mail-In Vote Fraud Claim
News FactCheck.org ·Conspiracy Theories Only Flourish With More Epstein Evidence
News NYT > Business > Media ·The Media Can't Stop Propping Up Elon Musk's Phony Supergenius Engineer Mythology
News commentary karlbode.com ·A Super Bowl ad promised ‘free money’ for kids. Here’s what Trump Accounts actually offer.
News Poynter ·Why We've Just Sued the Government
News newsguardrealitycheck.com ·A company that rates news sites says the Trump administration is strangling it
News The Washington Post ·NewsGuard Sues FTC, Claims Omnicom/IPG Merger Condition Unconstitutional
News MediaPost.com: MediaDailyNews ·Study: Fox News smeared Alex Pretti dozens of times following his killing by federal agents
News Media Matters for America ·Nearly Half of Americans Believed Top False Claims in 2025
News newsguardrealitycheck.com ·Beware: Government Using Image Manipulation For Propaganda
News commentary Techdirt ·Documentary about Poynter’s PolitiFact brings story of fact-checking to Japanese television
News release Poynter ·Let’s talk (again) about why fact-checking works
News commentary Poynter ·in brief
Fact checking: not a tool for all seasons
It was love at first sight, but over time, my ardor has cooled. I still believe there is value in cataloging misstatements, exaggerations, and, well, lies. But when government policies are undertaken and justified by nothing more than a fever-dream of fantasy and fiction, fact checking doesn’t meet the moment.
Sept. 27, 2024