The Times and its critics
The New York Times is the most important — and successful — news organization in the United States, with unmatched resources. But its political coverage has its critics, including a growing number of veteran journalists.
The Latest
The yin and yang of the New York Times in the Trump era
News commentary margaretsullivan.substack.com ·The New York Times came thisclose to having the Graham Platner rape story. So what happened?
News commentary Media Nation ·New York Times’ Kristof quoted former campaign donors in columns
News semafor.com ·The Two Sides of The Times
News Status ·The media’s desperate search for ‘moderate Nazis’
News commentary Stop the Presses ·The New York Times and Our Freedom
News commentary Second Rough Draft ·Whose Quotes Get Cleaned Up? How News Orgs Normalize Some Voices and Scrutinize Others.
News analysis storybench.org ·The Times’ Kristof Controversy
News status.news ·How We Chose What to Ask and When to Challenge Tucker Carlson
News NYT > Business > Media ·'They’re not interested in press freedom.' Margaret Sullivan on journalism's billionaire barons and the Substack upstarts out-hustling them.
News Long Lead Presents: Depth Perception ·New York Times finally reports on concerns that Trump is ‘clearly insane’
News commentary Press Watch ·It's great that the NYT is thriving. But I have a worry.
News commentary American Crisis ·Response from NYT journalists on two complaints about Iran coverage
News commentary American Crisis ·At the Times and the Post, solid reporting with a mealy-mouthed presentation
News commentary Press Watch ·Is The New York Times a games company? A familiar debate continues
News Nieman Lab ·Yes! THIS is how it's done, New York Times
News American Crisis ·Tension at The Times
News Status ·A directive from above': Former NYT editor lays out how the paper pushes anti-trans bigotry
News commentary transnews.network ·The NYT Recruiting Brochure for New College
News commentary donmoynihan.substack.com ·Shame will haunt New York Times leadership
News commentary Nieman Lab ·in brief
The Times and Post: diverging paths, but a shared fixation on Mamdani
It’s a tale of two newspapers.
March 19, 2026
Too many frogs to count
Millions of Americans gathered in thousands of cities and towns this past weekend to call for the restoration of democracy in the United States, and if you weren’t there, you still probably heard about it, since it was the lead story on news sites across the country. Except at the New York Times.
Oct. 21, 2025
Editorial decisions are now business decisions, and it’s not going well
News and information have a bedrock role in supporting democracy, but that’s not the business model we’ve chosen for newsrooms.
May 30, 2024
On democracy: The New York Times and its critics
Kathryn Schulz’s book “Being Wrong” is a wonderful exploration of human error. Highly recommended. I’m guessing no one in the New York Times leadership ever read it.
May 14, 2024