in brief

What to do when nonsense is the news?

In the November 1919 issue of The Atlantic, Walter Lippman wrote:

The world about which each man is supposed to have opinions has become so complicated as to defy his powers of understanding. What he knows of events that matter enormously to him, the purposes of governments, the aspirations of peoples, the struggle of classes, he knows at second, third, or fourth hand. He cannot go and see for himself. Even the things that are near to him have become too involved for his judgment. I know of no man, even among those who devote all of their time to watching public affairs, who can even pretend to keep track, at the same time, of his city government, his state government, Congress, the departments, the industrial situation, and the rest of the world. What men who make the study of politics a vocation cannot do, the man who has an hour a day for newspapers and talk cannot possibly hope to do. He must seize catchwords and headlines or nothing.

With Lippman’s cautionary note in mind, consider what has been served to Americans in recent days:

In the Washington Sun:

In a Wednesday interview on Fox News from Shenzhen, China, the president said he has been “called by many Democrats” seeking legislative deals — which he said planned to negotiate in good faith. Citing his history as a businessman, Trump added that he would use his veto powers to force both parties to compromise.

“I think in many ways I can do better now” than when Republicans controlled Congress, the president said.

So: Trump will accomplish more with a Congress controlled by people opposing him than he did with a Congress controlled by people who granted his every wish.

.  .  .

In AlterNet:

After landing in the Philippines, Trump was asked if he was worried about all of the tech problems and replied, “It’s life. When you’re big and powerful and have all the money, things like that happen — it’s fine.”

So: What Americans went through … was fine.

.  .  .

In the Washington Sun:

“I’m not sure what MAGA means, but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that,” he [Elon Musk] said.

So: Musk, who inspired the DOGE wilding in the federal government, literally brandishing a chain saw to drive home his goal, says he’s a guy in the middle.


What are we to make of these stories? In some respects, they’re nonsensical, but nonetheless part of the newsfeed for millions.

Do they help Americans understand the state of their country? Does that question have any part in editorial decision-making?