in brief

The Times suggests political caution; maybe that’s the wrong measure

The New York Times a week ago opined on the recent election, to let us know What Actually Happened and What it Means:

President Trump’s unpopularity was clearly the main engine of the Democratic Party’s resounding midterm victory. But his unpopularity alone did not deliver the scale of the Democrats’ triumph. To win in places like Kansas, Ohio, South Carolina and Texas, Democratic candidates needed to persuade many voters who previously considered their party unacceptable. The candidates’ success offers a road map to a sensible future for the party.

How did they do it? The simplest summary is that they ran as economic populists and cultural moderates.

That combination is consistent with American public opinion, which leans center-left on many economic issues and center-right on many social issues. By taking this approach, candidates were able to present themselves as beholden to neither of the country’s two political parties, both of which remain unpopular. The heterodox combination also has much to recommend it substantively. It meets the moment, after years of disappointing laissez-faire economic policies and a decade of cultural excesses by the progressive left.

The estimable Parker Molloy was not having it:

Pundits and partisans always say the results proved them right (I wrote about that on Election Day, and the Times opinion section has a version of its own: after elections, especially in recent years, it tells Democrats to drop their culture fights. Republicans don’t tend to get told they need to moderate. I wanted to make sure I wasn’t imagining it, so I went back and counted.

I took the opinion pieces the Times published in the 11 days starting on each Election Day since 2010, nine elections in all, and looked for ones that told either party to back off a culture-war position (on trans rights, immigration, policing, “wokeness” and the like) or said that backing off was the lesson of the result.

Since 2016, I found 24 pieces telling Democrats to back off and four telling Republicans to. Democrats got nine after they lost in 2024 and seven after they won this month. (The other eight: two in 2016, two in 2020 and four in 2022. There were none in 2018, though Bret Stephens’s column from that week, which I’ve written about before, comes close; it mostly told Democrats to become “a shrewder, humbler opposition party.”) Republicans got none after either of Trump’s wins and none after their losses in 2018 and 2020. Their four came after the 2022 midterms, when they won the House but not the Senate, and after this month’s wipeout.

Sign me up for Team Molloy.

But what I’d really like to see is journalists move away from covering policy as politics, first, last, and always. The debate over the “sweet spot” on an arbitrary ideological spectrum misses the point: Voters were clear in their revulsion of the current state of affairs, and equally clear on their grievances.

If I’m newly elected, addressing those grievances is job one. If I’m a journalist, covering them should be.