News commentary

These Are Not Serious People.

Breaking the News · James Fallows · last updated

This morning’s print edition of The New York Times Magazine has a long cover story by me titled “Is Air Travel Getting Less Safe?”

The story’s main argument is that the culture and institutions that have made US air travel exceptionally safe are at fundamental odds with the culture and practices of DOGE/MAGA/Project 2025. To wit:

  • Aviation safety depends on ruthless honesty about risks, mistakes, and failures. On a refusal to make excuses or shift blame. On respect and protection for those who ask “What if?” or say “Hey, wait a minute.” On transparency and coordination among the diverse people and institutions who share responsibility for life-and-death stakes. All of whom take that burden seriously.

And by contrast:

  • The DOGE/MAGA regime features impatience with collaboration and coordination, contempt for bureaucracy or institutional memory, glee at wielding the chainsaw and seeing how things look once the dust has blown away. On quick fixes, snarky videos, and an insistence on always having been right.

Overall this is “move fast and break things,” versus “better safe than sorry.” In the article I tell the stories of how a culture based on “learning the lessons written in blood” has averted tragedies, and why upending that culture could have tragic consequences.

I had been working on that piece for many months; it’s why I put this site on pause over the summer. Little did I imagine that its publication would coincide with a failure of the aviation system that commanded attention while fortunately not costing lives. That was of course the nationwide shutdown three days ago.

We learn a lot about people and organizations when they’re under stress. Rudolf Giuliani earned respect that lasted years (but not forever) for his steely resolve in leading New York after the 9/11 attacks. George W. Bush’s reputation, already battered by the Iraq war, never recovered from publicly telling his head of FEMA, Michael Brown, “Brownie, you’re doing a heckuva job” amid the ruins from Hurricane Katrina.

What we’ve learned about the government team now under stress from the lockdown is a vivid illustration of what I discussed in the story. They’re not up to this moment. We need help to keep us safe.

Share


Public Flailing, in Three Acts.

This administration’s message to a travel-stranded public has come in three installments. None of them featured the president, who by contrast has gone before the cameras at a moment’s notice to speak about his ballroom or reflecting pool. Instead as time has gone on, they have left the explaining more and more to one figure in the spotlight’s narrowing focus. That is the former MTV reality-show star and five-term Wisconsin congressman Sean Duffy, who has now become Secretary of Transportation.

Duffy was sworn in as Secretary just a day before the horrific Potomac River collision early last year, the worst US aviation accident since 2009. He came to office with zero experience in aviation, which is not in itself disqualifying. The same was true of many of his predecessors, including the two most recent: Pete Buttigieg and Elaine Chao.

What’s striking about Duffy is how little he seems to have learned since arriving nearly two years ago. He spent much of last summer not on anything aviation-related but rather on a six-episode reality-show road trip with his family across the country, sponsored by Boeing, Waymo, and other companies he regulates.1 A speech he gave not long after taking office is strikingly similar in platitudes and details to what he has been saying over these past three days.2 The interviews and speeches I’ve seen are generalized praise for exciting new measures by the Trump team, and generalized blame for Biden era failures and woke-ism.3

What have we learned from him, and about him, as he has become the sole administration spokesperson?


1) Friday evening: ‘I want $50 billion!’

Around 8:30 that evening, more than four hours into the shutdown, Duffy and Markwayne Mullin, successor to Kristi Noem at Homeland Security, appeared jointly in the White House briefing room for the first official information since the shutdown. Where had Donald Trump been through that time? Who knows.

They both announced two important pieces of information: That there was no evidence of a terrorist or cyber attack, and that the national airspace was once again opened. They disagreed on fundamentals of what had occurred: Mullin said that it arose when new equipment was being connected to old; Duffy, that it was a failure of old systems. Beyond that, neither had details to offer.

They agreed on several points: That blame lay with “the Democrat party” for having saddled them with this mess. And that the nation was blessed in its current leadership. “This is the greatest country, with the greatest president,” Duffy said midway through the presentation. Mullin closed the press conference with: “[As] Secretary Duffy said, he’s the greatest president we’ve had. You’ve never had a builder and a leader like President Trump.” It was like one of Trump’s televised cabinet meetings. It was unlike the way any previous cabinet secretaries had talked about previous presidents.

And they agreed that more money was the answer. “The president’s asked for 30 billion dollars,” Duffy said. “I want 50 billion dollars!” He said that the system was falling apart. “Many of our towers are almost 100 years old.” I will bet him $50 billion he cannot show me one such operating tower, let alone “many.”

What neither of them did was admit the slightest responsibility, misjudgment, or contrition for anything that had occurred. On their own part, or anyone else’s on Team Trump. It was all someone else’s fault.


2) Saturday morning: ‘I’m sorry,’ but not from the bosses.

Yesterday morning, as airports and airlines groaned back into a degree of functionality, Duffy (minus Markwayne) appeared at a press conference with two people who actually know about aviation. One was Brian Bedford, a former airline CEO who is now in charge of the FAA. The other was Rebecca Guy, a longtime FAA official who is now their acting chief technology officer.

Several times during the conference, Bedford took over the microphone from Duffy, when he was drifting from generalization to outright error.4 Or they turned to Guy for details.

Duffy seemed there mainly for political messaging: For instance, that most spending for airspace improvements was in “Democrat cities”—so why should Democrats be so ungrateful? And how a generalized “Congress” should have been pouring more money into his projects—never mind that Republican had ironclad control of both houses, never mind that Trump and Russell Vought had obtained funding for what they cared about, including some $50 billion for detention centers and $75 billion in multi-year appropriations for ICE. “Congress is the problem!” “Wait, who controls Congress?”

The most striking moment of the press conference came a few minutes in, with the very first words to cross Brian Bedford’s lips. “I’d like to start with a sincere apology to the American traveling public,” he said. Bedford has occasioned some controversies within aviation. But this is the way the flying world is used to speaking about failures and missteps.

It is the only such sentiment I am aware of, from the current leadership.


3) Sunday morning: ‘All the Shows’ blitz.

Read more