News commentary

For right-wing media, free speech in the classroom is reserved for anti-trans teachers

Media Matters for America · Media Matters for America · last updated

A Florida school declined to renew the contract of a “beloved” teacher after she addressed a student by a chosen name rather than their legal name without parental permission. The teacher was accused of violating a 2023 state law requiring written parental consent for teachers to use any name for a student that isn’t their legal one — even nicknames.

While right-wing media have repeatedly championed educators who violate policies in service of their anti-LGBTQ views, their response to this case of a teacher violating a policy regulating speech in schools has been less enthusiastic.

Moreover, harassment campaigns against teachers who are trans or trans-affirming remain a staple for right-wing pundits.

Related Knowledge Center: Information integrity

State of Play

In an increasingly fractured media landscape, truth has been a casualty in the public discussion. Coverage has been warped by the business needs of struggling news organizations, and a significant segment of the public relies on bad-faith outlets that are little more than propagandists. While fact-checking has become routine, some organizations are exploring other ways to combat the trends. And misinformation spewed by AI-driven chatbots has become more of a feature than simply a bug. 

Fact-checking and its detractors


More informationabout Information integrity

Related Knowledge Center: Democracy and politics

State of Play

News organizations are scrambling to find a coverage approach that adequately informs the American public about the country’s slide from democracy to authoritarian rule.

The White House vs. the press


More informationabout Democracy and politics