News

Punished for asking a question

cnn.com · Brian Stelter · last updated

Today in Shenzhen: “The latest example of China’s strict controls on news coverage and how tightly Beijing tries to stage-manage major international events.”

That’s how The New York Times described it.

President Trump was said to be perturbed by the relative lack of press access during his bilateral meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping.

And then, during the trilateral with Trump, Xi and Russian leader Vladimir Putin, Bloomberg reporter Annmarie Hordern was banned from the room.

It was “commendable” that the White House was “advocating for press access” during the events in Shenzhen, White House Correspondents’ Association president Jacqui Heinrich said.

Heinrich also interviewed Trump live on Fox soon after sunrise in Shenzhen. Later that day, local time, as reporters observed Trump and Xi’s meeting, Hordern called out a question: “President Trump, has Jensen Huang been disloyal to the United States?”

Afterward, one of the US press pool reporters on the trip said “the Chinese have passed along a message that yelling questions is considered extremely rude and we will be pulled from the room if we do so.”

And Hordern was, indeed, banned from the trilateral meeting.

“A WH official said they pushed to have her reinstated but Chinese officials insisted she be excluded,” according to a pool reporter note.

Jack Posobiec, of all people, said he was standing next to Hordern when she shouted the question. Posobiec, who infamously stoked the Pizzagate conspiracy theory ten years ago, has refashioned himself as an editor for Human Events.

He wrote on X after the incident, “The 1st Amendment really means something when you see countries without it.”

Indeed. Now, it’s also worth pointing out, as Politico’s Josh Gerstein did in a reply to Posobiec, that “Trump has selectively excluded AP, CNN, MS NOW & POLITICO from many of his events, although judges enforcing America’s great First Amendment have reversed much of those bans.”

But at least on this occasion, the Trump administration defended the role of the press.

As for the sit-down with Xi and Putin, “diplomatic breakthroughs, it turned out, were not the point. The talks themselves were the deliverable,” CNN’s Kevin Liptak and Simone McCarthy wrote here…