No, Ross Douthat, a chain-owned ghost newspaper is not better than a community news website

Ross Douthat has a long, mildly worded anti-tech rant in today’s New York Times that I enjoyed, even if I didn’t take it too seriously. A lot of it read like Douthat’s Greatest Hits, hastily written and not especially well thought-through.

But I do want to offer a brief comment on this, plucked from his long list of ways in which the real is better than the virtual: “Online sources of local news are generally lousy compared with the vanished ecosystem of print newspapers.”

Like I said, the whole thing read like he wasn’t putting a lot of thought into it. But we all know that the digital local news outlets that have sprouted in recent years are often better and more comprehensive than the chain-owned ghost newspapers they replaced.

Many of them are nonprofit. Some also have print editions; most don’t. But the idea that a community news website is “lousy” compared to a corporate print product filled with so-called news from anywhere except the community it purports to cover is laughable.

If Douthat would like to go back, say, two or three generations, to a time when many communities had locally owned newspapers with full-time staff members and their own printing press, well, yes. But like I said, he’s produced a once-over-lightly for a day when few people will be spending much time with the Sunday paper.

Happy Easter, everyone!