Just Stop Oil Activists Sentenced for Attack on Van Gogh Painting

Just Stop Oil Activists Sentenced for Attack on Van Gogh Painting - The New York Times

Supported by

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Van Gogh ‘Sunflowers’ Targeted Again as Protesters Are Sentenced to Jail

A judge said he hoped to deter protests when he handed down lengthy terms for the two activists, who dumped soup on the painting in 2022. Later that day, activists did it again.

When a London judge handed down prison sentences on Friday to two climate activists, who threw soup on Vincent van Gogh’s “Sunflowers,” he said he wanted to deter protesters from trying similar stunts.

Judge Christopher Hehir sentenced Phoebe Plummer, 23, to two years in jail for damaging the painting’s frame during the 2022 attack at the National Gallery in London. Anna Holland, 22, received 20 months for the same offense. Their actions were “criminally idiotic” and could have caused “irreversible damage” to a masterpiece, Judge Hehir said.

His words did not have the desired effect.

Just over an hour later, three other members of Plummer and Holland’s protest group, Just Stop Oil, entered the National Gallery’s “ Van Gogh: Poets and Lovers” exhibition and threw Heinz vegetable soup over the painting again. They also splashed the orange liquid on another van Gogh “Sunflowers” painting, on loan from the Philadelphia Museum of Art for the gallery’s blockbuster show.

In a video of the incident, released on social media by Just Stop Oil, museum patrons appear startled. One person shouts: “Why are you doing that?” The London police said it had arrested the three activists.

A National Gallery spokeswoman said in an emailed statement that “the paintings were removed from display and examined by a conservator and are unharmed.” The museum would “reopen the exhibition as soon as possible,” the statement added.

A spokeswoman for the Philadelphia Museum of Art said that the National Gallery had informed the museum “that the painting has been cleaned and there is no permanent damage.”

Climate protesters have been grabbing media attention with stunts in museums since 2022, in a wave of actions that began in the Louvre in Paris and then spread to England, Germany, Italy and the United States.

Friday’s jail terms were the heaviest penalties handed down by a British court in response to such attacks. A protester who glued himself to the frame of another van Gogh work, “Peach Trees in Blossom,” at the Courtauld Gallery in London, was sentenced to a three-week prison term in 2022, but most activists have avoided jail time. Five Just Stop Oil members who stuck themselves to the frame around a copy of Leonardo da Vinci’s “The Last Supper” and spray-painted the phrase, “No new oil,” on a wall at the Royal Academy were each fined £486, about $650.

During Plummer and Holland’s sentencing hearing, Judge Hehir said that acidic soup had a “corrosive effect” on the painting’s 17th-century wood frame and had lowered the frame’s value by an estimated 10,000 pounds, or about $13,000.

The judge said the duo’s action came close to damaging the masterpiece itself — within “the thickness of a pane of glass.” He added that “stupidity like this” could lead museums to withdraw cultural treasures from public view, or force them to introduce onerous security measures that would deter visitors.

During the hearing, Plummer, who uses they/them pronouns, read a lengthy speech in which they said that protest was a vital tool for raising awareness of climate change. Judge Hehir interrupted repeatedly: “I’ve heard it before,” he said at one point. After Plummer said they were “a political prisoner,” Judge Hehir interrupted to say, “We don’t have political prisoners in this country.”

Raj Chada, a lawyer representing Holland, told the court that the defendants had not intended to damage the painting and knew the museum had covered it with glass to protect it. Judge Hehir dismissed that argument saying the pair had blithely ignored the risks to van Gogh’s painting.

Plummer told the court that they expected a jail term and would accept the judgment “with a smile,” and as a member of the court staff led them away to start their sentence, they grinned. Then the pair hugged and blew kisses at their supporters in the courtroom.

Alex Marshall is a Times reporter covering European culture. He is based in London. More about Alex Marshall

Vincent van Gogh,
National Gallery (London)

The Vast World of Art and Design

-
MoMa’s Robert Frank Exhibit: The museum’s centenary exhibition of the artist revered for “The Americans,” a groundbreaking book,
makes the case for his later work, after he renounced photography for filmmaking.
-
South Carolina’s Indigo: In South Carolina’s Lowcountry, artists, farmers and designers are
writing a new chapter in indigo’s rich and tangled history.
-
Mother Nature Is His Accomplice: Brandon Ndife’s otherworldly domestic sculptures
swallow up space in his Brooklyn studio. His work, which shows nature’s ungovernable power, is on view in a show in New York.
-
Filmmaking as Therapy: Why have so many children of architects
made films about their parents? Jim Venturi shines a light on his father and mother, the postmodern innovators Robert Venturi and Denise Scott Brown.
-
Procession of Angels: The artist María Magdalena Campos-Pons is marshaling New Yorkers for unity,
linking uptown and downtown communities while highlighting inequities in city parks.