News commentary

Hoosier Journalistic Paragon?

Columbia Journalism Review · Bill Grueskin · last updated

“WE ________ JOURNALISTS MUST STAND TOGETHER.”

That all-caps headline ran on the front page of a newspaper a few days ago. Can you fill in the blank?

[Waiting…]

If you guessed “WHITE HOUSE,” just know that we find your naïveté sweetly (but sadly) endearing.

If you guessed “PENTAGON,” you are getting much warmer.

And if you guessed “STUDENT,” come collect your winnings (which consist of our admiration for your brilliance)

This all came about after administrators at Indiana University cracked down on the Indiana Daily Student newspaper. IDS editors had planned to include actual news in the print edition, not just gauzy stuff about homecoming and football. The university thought that real journalistic content should go only online, and halted this and future print editions. Then, David Tolchinsky, dean of the Media School, fired the director of student media who wouldn’t cater to the university’s demands.

To the ramparts marched the journalists at The Exponent, the student paper at Purdue University. They published around three thousand copies of a “solidarity edition,” which they distributed at their rival campus, a couple of hours away. Students deposited the papers, with the “WE STUDENT JOURNALISTS MUST STAND TOGETHER” cover, at around thirty newsstands on the IU campus. The content was almost entirely the work of Purdue students, with headlines like “The Exponent stands with the IDS after director fired, paper censored” and “At Indiana University, the journalism school forgot what journalism is for.” As Exponent editor Olivia Mapes wrote, “Prohibiting the IDS from publishing the news…defeats the entire purpose of a newspaper.” Purdue folks also covered the cost, less than a thousand dollars, Exponent publisher Kyle Charters told me. 

Related Knowledge Center: Free speech and public protest

State of Play

The First Amendment is facing challenging times: Crackdowns on campus protests prompted both-sides claims of intolerance. Attempts to head off dangerous health misinformation have been characterized as violations of free speech. Donald Trump is publicly punishing news outlets that deviate from his administration’s version of events while privately suing some outlets into submission.

The White House vs. the press  |  Voiceless America 


More informationabout Free speech and public protest

Related Knowledge Center: Local media

State of Play

The hollowing out of the local news ecosystem has been well documented; in some communities, efforts are underway to reverse the growing news desert.


More informationabout Local media