Guatemala in Crisis as Hunger Rises and Migrants Flee - Reuters.com

Guatemala in Crisis as Hunger Rises and Migrants Flee

In a warming world, hunger stalks Guatemala's Mayan highlands

Crop failures are one reason an unprecedented number of migrants are heading to the U.S. border.

In a warming world, hunger stalks Guatemala's Mayan highlands

Crop failures are one reason an unprecedented number of migrants are heading to the U.S. border.

A few tortillas and a half bowl of reheated beans were all Maria Concepcion Rodriguez had to feed her six children in the isolated village of El Aguacate, one day in August.

Only her three-month-old breastfed baby had height commensurate with her age. The others were stunted by undernourishment. They looked too young for their years.

An image of Juan Carlos, the son of Maria Concepcion Rodriguez. As you scroll Juan Carlos transitions to sit next to his health carnet. Juan Carlos is too short for his age, or stunted, according to the World Health Organization standards. His height at 95 cm is compared on a line to the average normal length-for-age, which is 110 cm. In 2022, 44 percent of children in Guatemala fell outside of the normal height-for-age range, according to UNICEF.

When food runs out, Rodriguez, 30, asks neighbors for what they can spare. “If they don't have it, then we don't eat,” she said, speaking the Mayan language Achi. Like hers, scores of families in El Aguacate don't have enough on their plates.

A video of Maria Concepcion Rodriguez and her six children in their home eating tortillas and beans.

Maria Concepcion Rodriguez, 30, carrying her baby on her back, among her other children Joaquin, Claudia, Wilmer, Juan Carlos and Anibal, during lunch at her house in El Aguacate village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 16, 2023.

Guatemala's rate of stunting is the highest in Latin America, UNICEF data shows.

The rate is more than double that of the region's second highest, Ecuador. Globally only seven countries have higher levels than Guatemala, which is considered an upper-middle income country.

Stunting prevalence by country in 2022

A chart showing countries that rank from most stunting to least stunting. Burundi ranks worst with over 55% of children aged 0-5 in 2022 were classified as stunted. Guatemala ranks 8th with 43.5%.

As much as a quarter of Guatemala’s population - up to 4.6 million people - suffered food shortages over the past year, the highest rate since a system called the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) that generates data for the U.N. began projections for the whole of Guatemala in 2018.

The crisis has coincided with worsening extremes of rainfall and temperature, the fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic, and a period of political instability marked by the fight against corruption.

The weather extremes echo predictions by the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change of intensifying drought and its impact on agriculture and food security in a region called the Central American Dry Corridor, which Guatemala straddles.

Over the past decade, countries in the Dry Corridor have been hit by longer and deeper droughts as well as a series of hurricanes, causing widespread crop damage.

On a trip to the Guatemalan regions of Alta Verapaz and Baja Verapaz, Reuters met 10 families crippled by food insecurity, crop damage and heavy debts from migration attempts. All said they'd noticed less rain in recent years. At least 20 children seen by Reuters suffered severe malnutrition.

A map of Central America showing the dry corridor spanning across Guatemala, El Salvador, Nicaragua, and Honduras. Guatemala has an agricultural economy reliant on coffee, sugar, corn, and beans. It straddles a region known as the Central American Dry Corridor. The weather extremes being experienced in the Dry Corridor, one of the most climate-vulnerable areas on the planet, are in line with scientists’ predictions.

At least 127 deaths among young children were suspected to be linked to hunger in the first nine months of the year, up from 96 in the same period last year, Guatemalan government data shows.

There is growing consensus that crop damage from climate change is among the complex reasons for food shortages, and migration decisions, in Guatemala, a view supported by the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organization, a dozen experts consulted for this story and the U.S. State Department in a statement to Reuters.

“It is worse than ever, people in the countryside are starving,” said Donald J. Planty, former U.S. ambassador to Guatemala who now runs a consulting firm that works in Latin America. He said the United States was “just waking up” to the climate impact on hunger and migration in Central America.

Left:Top: Fidel Lopez Pacheco’s corn crops are seen in Las Tunas village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 17, 2023. Right:Bottom: One of Maria Concepcion Rodriguez’ children reaches for a tortilla during lunch in El Aguacate village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 16, 2023.

A U.S. State Department official said that along with other factors, “the increasingly severe impacts of climate change can serve as a powerful determinant in decisions to leave rural homes in search of a better life,” and that Washington was stepping up efforts to build resilience to climate change in Central America.

Guatemala's health ministry said climate change, Russia's war in Ukraine, inflation, and COVID all threatened food security in Guatemala and elsewhere.

In a statement to Reuters, the ministry highlighted that IPC projections for late 2023 showed a slight improvement over a year ago. They remain worse than previous measured years.

Outgoing President Alejandro Giammattei, himself a medical doctor, launched a national nutrition plan in 2020.

In an interview, President-elect Bernardo Arevalo, due to take office in January, said hunger and migration were tightly linked. To address them his government will invest to counter a “historical marginalization of Indigenous populations,” he said.

A video of a woman walking with her through a child care center.

Marta Itzcac walks with her 1-year-old son Brandon Ichich at the CAIMI Maternal and Child Care Center where cases of child malnutrition are treated in Alta Verapaz, Guatemala August 18, 2023.

“I WORRY SO MUCH”

At a nutrition clinic in San Cristobal, Alta Verapaz, officials deal with severe cases daily. The region has the country's highest morbidity and mortality from acute malnutrition.

A toddler with cerebral palsy cries in his mother's arms. Unable to chew, he can only take liquids.

He squirms but is mostly quiet as a nurse gently lays him on a digital scale. At two years old, he weighs less than 17 pounds (7.6 kg) – an average weight for a baby aged six months.

Top left:First: A worker measures 2-year-old Edgar Benjamin Pa Xol, who has cerebral palsy, at the CAIMI, Maternal and Child Care Center in Alta Verapaz, Guatemala. Top right:Second: A CAIMI nurse stands next to an incubator. Bottom:Third: Imelda Pa Xol, 23, carries Edgar at CAIMI. Pictures taken August 18, 2023.

“I worry so much that he is not going to recover,” his mother Imelda Pa Xol, said. “I can see he is not gaining weight.”

Next, the nurse straightens his legs to measure him. Uncomfortable, he begins to cry. At 75 centimeters, he is severely stunted. About 87 centimeters is average for his age, according to information in his health records.

Across the country, severe malnutrition cases among children under five were up by more than a third at nearly 21,400 as of September compared to the same period a year ago, according to Guatemalan government data.

“This is the most critical year... we have already been seeing this rise in cases and it is getting higher,” nutritionist Sinthia Perdomo said as she cared for children stunted by starvation. “Sadly, some of them die.”

Bedroom of Lorenzo Tista’s family in El Aguacate village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 16, 2023.

“MOST YOUNG MEN WANT TO LEAVE”

With crops failing, Fidel Eduardo Lopez, 53, has tried to migrate illegally to the United States three times since 2022, but was caught each time before he crossed the U.S border.

Lopez and his wife have noticed rainfall becoming more unpredictable in their farming village of Las Tunas over the years.

In the first harvest of this year, the yield from their small corn crop was a quarter of what it should be.

Lopez calculates he could pay debts and support his children with just one day's wages sent from the United States each week. “Things change for the family the moment you arrive,” he said.

An image of a family standing in front of a table with their basic food.

Adelaida Pacheco (R), her husband Fidel Lopez Pacheco, daughter-in-law Evelyn Raxaco and 1-year-old granddaughter Sherlyn Lopez, pose for a photo with their basic food, at home in Las Tunas Village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 17, 2023.

The number of Guatemalans arriving at the U.S. border soared fivefold from 2020 to 2022, Arrivals were 233,000 in 2022, close to record levels, according to U.S. data.

In a study published in 2021, scientists found Central American drought between 2015 and 2019 was likely made four times more probable due to human-caused climate change.

Scientists are not yet at a consensus on the exact human impact, according to University of Arizona's Talia Anderson, who conducted field research in Guatemala. Regardless of the causes, the Dry Corridor is a global hotspot for future drying, she said.

The most recent climate assessment by the U.N. climate science agency in 2021 projected a worsening impact on rural livelihoods and food security in the Dry Corridor, particularly for small and medium-sized farmers and Indigenous people. Seasonal-scale droughts are projected to lengthen, intensify and increase in frequency, it said.

Guatemala’s weather conditions

A line chart showing Guatemala’s weather conditions by looking at the 24-month Standardized Precipitation-Evapotranspiration Index since 1955. From 1955 to 1985, Guatemala had wetter than average conditions. From 1985 through August 2023, Guatemala has had drier than average conditions.

The weather extremes are in line with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's predictions of intensifying drought and its impact on agriculture and food security.

The panel’s most recent assessment in 2021 projects a worsening impact on rural livelihoods and food security in the Dry Corridor, particularly for small and medium-sized farmers and Indigenous people. Seasonal-scale droughts are projected to lengthen, intensify and increase in frequency, the panel said.

Speaking beside the main water source for El Aguacate, a rocky river bed with just a few inches of water in the center, Ruben Jordan, an aid worker with Care International said the local production system was “totally lost” because of intervals of up to 25 days without rain.

“With the drought this year, we already lost the first harvest,” said Juan Olmino, 73, a farmer in the village, who grows corn, beans and other vegetables. “Most young men here want to leave.”

But Rodriguez and her husband are too poor to even consider migration. She starts a fire, the only way to cook in her home, where she has no running water or electricity.

Smoke fills her dirt-floor adobe house, where the family shares a few hammocks for sleeping. She warms the leftover beans and prepares the tortillas.

A video of Maria Concepcion Rodriguez making tortillas over a fire from corn grown on a small patch of land the family rents for subsistence farming.

Maria Concepcion Rodriguez, 30, mother of six children, prepares tortillas for lunch at her house in El Aguacate village in Baja Verapaz, Guatemala August 16, 2023.