Canada Announces Carbon Emission Caps for Oil and Gas Sectors

Canada Announces Carbon Emission Caps for Oil and Gas Sectors - The New York Times

Supported by
SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Canada Moves to Limit Oil and Gas Industry Carbon Emissions

The Trudeau government has focused on the oil and gas production industries because the large amounts of energy they use make them the country’s largest source of greenhouse gases.

Canada announced regulations on Monday to cap carbon emissions from its oil and gas industry and reduce the release of greenhouse gases, a move bitterly opposed by the energy industry and met with lukewarm support from some environmentalists who say the rules are not strict enough.

Canadian officials said the country would cut emissions from its energy sector by 35 percent to 38 percent over 2019 levels by 2030. The regulations, which include financial incentives and credits, flesh out the announcement last December by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government that it intended to limit emissions.

The United States is the largest importer of Canadian fossil fuels, with most coming from oil sands in Alberta, which require large amounts of energy for production.

Canada’s oil and gas industry is the country’s largest source of carbon emissions, accounting for about one-third of the overall total.

While some oil sands operations have reduced the amount of carbon emitted for each barrel they produce, overall production has increased, raising emissions from oil sands by 142 percent over the last 19 years.

The Canadian government imposed taxes on carbon that helped reduce emissions in many sectors of the economy from 1990 to 2022. Still, Canada’s overall greenhouse gas emissions rose by 16.5 percent during that period, largely because the oil and gas industry raised their production levels.

“It is a significant moment for Canada,” Julia Levin, the associate director for climate at Environmental Defence, an environmental group, said before the announcement. “But there are troublesome loopholes.”

These include, she noted, allowing companies that fail to meet the caps to buy what are in effect exceptions.

Climate change has been a key issue for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government, but the emissions cap and its regulations underscore the politically difficult balancing act Mr. Trudeau faces.

While many environmental groups and climate scientists say fossil fuel needs to be phased out in favor of green energy, Mr. Trudeau has long insisted that Canada needs a strong oil industry to finance the transition away from fossil fuels.

That commitment extended to the government buying an oil pipeline from its American owner and paying for its expansion.

The government says the cap, which will take effect in 2030, is not an effort to curbing oil and gas production, but only to reduce carbon emissions.

Alberta, which relies on energy royalties for its budget, has launched an advertising campaign opposing the cap, which it says will hobble the industry and cut jobs.

An alliance of the largest oil sands companies have proposed installing equipment to capture carbon dioxide and then send it through pipelines to store it in underground reservoirs, a process known as carbon capture and storage. The federal government said it would offer energy companies tens of billions of dollars in tax credits to subsidize those systems, though there is still skepticism about the technical and financial viability of large-scale carbon capture.

The regulations released on Monday said energy companies that reduce their emissions will be given credits by the government. They will be able to sell them to other oil and gas firms that have not met required emissions reduction targets. Companies that have not met emissions targets will also have the option to pay into a fund to support carbon reduction programs.

Ms. Levin, the environmentalist, said the cap should be put in place before 2030 because more urgent action was needed to address the impact of greenhouse gases.

She also noted that the governments carbon emission reduction level for the energy sector falls short of Canada’s overall goal for lowering emissions. Canada has said it would reduce carbon emissions as a whole by 40 to 45 percent by 2030 from 2010 levels.

She noted that the new measures will do nothing to limit the carbon emissions created when Canadian oil and gas exported to the United States is actually burned. The United States buys about 80 percent of Canada’s production.

“Sticking our heads in the sand, Ms. Levin said, means we’ll be unprepared when demand for Canada’s oil, some of the dirtiest and expensive in the world, collapses.”

The regulations released on Monday are drafts and are not scheduled to go into effect until the spring of next year.

But it is unclear if Mr. Trudeau’s government will still be in power. His Liberal Party does not control a majority of votes in the House of Commons and it trails the Conservatives by double digits in polls.

A national election must be held by next October and Conservatives, whose power base is in Alberta, could rescind the proposed emissions cap regulations. They have relentlessly campaigned against Mr. Trudeau’s carbon tax.

Ian Austen reports on Canada for The Times based in Ottawa. He covers politics, culture and the people of Canada and has reported on the country for two decades. He can be reached at austen@nytimes.com. More about Ian Austen
Justin Trudeau

Around the World With The Times

Our reporters across the globe take you into the field.

-
What Sank the Bayesian?: A Times investigation has found that a British tech mogul’s superyacht that capsized off Italy had
an unorthodox design that made it vulnerable.
-
A New Threat to Brazil’s Forests: Brazilian authorities are using satellites to track deforestation caused by chain saws or fire.
Now criminals are turning to chemicals to degrade trees — and evade detection.
-
Can Miss Universe Ever Go Home?: Sheynnis Palacios was the first Nicaraguan to win the crown, becoming a hero in her homeland.
Then things got complicated with her country’s authoritarian government.
-
Adopting a New Language: The Cia-Cia tribe in Indonesia has passed down its language orally for centuries. Now the tribe’s children are
learning to write it in Hangul, the Korean script.
-
Afghanistan’s Best Hope for Change?: Sirajuddin Haqqani has tried to remake himself from blood-soaked jihadist to pragmatic Taliban statesman.
Western diplomats are shocked — and enticed.